In the past two decades, owing largely to progress in counterfactual, graphical, and structural analyses, causal ity has been transformed into a mathematical theory with. Jan 06, 2014 speakers judea pearl and elias bareinboim. The counterfactual or potential outcome model has become increasingly standard for causal inference in epidemiological and medical studies. Gertler, sebastian martinez, patrick premand, laura b. The logic of counterfactuals in causal inference discussion. Review of counterfactuals and causal inference 4 chose, then an average difference in the values of can be given a causal interpretation morgan and winship, 2007, p. Causality and statistical learning 1 andrew gelman 2 24 feb 2010. A refined method for theorybased evaluation of the societal impacts. Therefore, experimental and statistical approaches to causal inference are. These include causal interactions, imperfect experiments, adjustment for.
The graphical approach to causal inference using directed acyclic graphs dags is equivalent to the potential outcomes approach to causal inference. Treatment effects, random experiments, and selection bias. Counterfactuals and causal reasoning adventures in why. This module discusses the importance of counterfactuals in causal inference, and the idea of irrefutability. Bibliographic record and links to related information available from the library of congress catalog. For a recent collection of essays in philosophy on counterfactuals and causation, see collins, hall, and paul 2004. I have read many of causal inference books and this is, i would say, is the clearest one.
The approach also does not account for counterfactuals, so a proxy is needed in lieu. Some people would have visited the websiteplatform and bought even if the camp. We instead focus on populationlevel estimands, such as the average causal e. This paper provides an overview on the counterfactual and related approaches. Causal inference without counterfactuals created date. Introduction inferences about counterfactuals are essential for prediction, answering what if questions, and estimating causal e. Comments on michael jordans essay the ai revolution hasnt. In the past three decades, a counterfactual model of causality has been devel. In this second edition of counterfactuals and causal inference, completely revised and expanded, the essential features of the counterfactual approach to observational data analysis are presented with examples from the social, demographic, and health sciences. True randomized experiments can provide compelling evidence on the causal relation between two variables. The study of counterfactual speculation has increasingly engaged the interest of scholars in a wide range of domains such. Causal inference without counterfactuals with comments and rejoinder.
The science of why things occur is called etiology. Causal inference is tricky and should be used with great caution. The potential outcomes framework is a main statistical approach to causal inference, in. It would repeatedly demonstrate the techniques with numerical examples unless you are completely convinced.
Section 7 questions the role of an implicit attitude of fatalism in some counterfactual causal models and methods. Vermeersch impact evaluation in practice, second edition published. For every individual, u, there is a function that specifies the state of u s infection under two hypothetical conditions. Read counterfactuals and causal inference methods and principles for social research by stephen l. Causal inference conditional independence counterfactual analysis concomitant variable predictive inference these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This paper extends the work in counterfactual explanations by. Introduction to causal inference without counterfactuals a. Causal analysis in theory and practice counterfactual. Download citation on jan 1, 2000, judea pearl and others published the logic of counterfactuals in causal inference discussion of causal inference without counterfactuals by a.
Back and front door partial compliance and instrumental variables. Heather stoll, gary king, langche zeng inferences about counterfactuals are essential for prediction, answering what if questions, and estimating causal effects. The role of counterfactual theory in causal reasoning. The causal effect of racial discrimination is the difference between two outcomes. Causal inference principle i suppose we wish to estimate the causal effect of a on y. There are very large literatures associated with each of these frameworks, but the connections, which will be highlighted in this tutorial, are often. A missing data perspective peng ding fan li 1 abstract inferring causal effects of treatments is a central goal in many disciplines. Dawid has argued that counterfactuals were something metaphysical because causal inference based on counterfactuals would depend on unobservable assumptions. Causal inference is the process of drawing a conclusion about a causal connection based on the conditions of the occurrence of an effect. And this second edition by morgan and winship will bring. Counterfactuals, thought experiments, and singular causal analysis in history julian reiss thought experiments are ubiquitous in science and especially prominent in domains in which experimental and observational evidence is scarce. Counterfactual theories of causation stanford encyclopedia.
Review of counterfactuals and causal inference 1 book. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. Wewill discuss the broader philosophical literature in chapters 8 and 10, as it does have some implications. After you optimize the campaign for it to reach its full potential, there is a question that remains. Sep, 2005 dawid has argued that counterfactuals were something metaphysical because causal inference based on counterfactuals would depend on unobservable assumptions. Limits to credible inferences about such causal estimands come in at least two varieties manski 2007.
Causal inference without counterfactuals 409 modeling and decision analysis, and shows how it delivers an unambiguous conclusion, avoiding the above problems. If c is a common cause of a and y then we should control for c c a y if we do not control for c, then the association we observe between a and y may not be due to the causal effect of a on y. The most important concept in causal inference is that of the counterfactual most causal inference statisticians define causal effects as comparisons between what would happen in two or more different states one of which will be factual, the others counterfactual examples headache status one hour after taking ibuprofin. How do you measure the true effectiveness that your campaign had. But, first, let us ask why anyone would be interested in locating counterfactuals in the graph. Readers will quickly realize that the ideas, methods, and tools discussed on this blog were kept out of this book. An introduction to causal inference, with extensions to. It focuses on one of the most active areas of recent research. A popular approach to causal inference is based on counterfactuals. The guiding idea behind counterfactual analyses of causation is the thought that as david lewis puts it we think of a cause as something that makes a difference, and the difference it makes must be a difference from what would have happened without it. Philosophically, a counterfactual statement is an assertion of the form if x had been the case, then y would have happened, made when it is known to be false that x is the case. Causal inference and the assessment of racial discrimination.
To construct interpretable explanations that are also consistent with the original ml model, counterfactual examplesshowing how the models output changes with small perturbations to the inputhave been proposed. This tutorial offers a unified introduction to the modern theory of causality based on counterfactuals aka potential outcomes, directed acyclic graphs dags and nonparametric structural equation models npsems. Introduction to causal inference without counterfactuals. Causal explanation,the counterfactual approach to causality championed by. May 03, 2016 after you optimize the campaign for it to reach its full potential, there is a question that remains. Counterfactuals and causal inference ebook by stephen l. This book presents a model and set of methods for causal effect estimation that social scientists can use to address causal questions such as these. We are informed of another book on causal inference. Causal inference is one of the most important, most subtle, and most neglected of all the prob lems of statistics dawid 1979. There are two di erent languages for saying the same thing. Counterfactuals much recent analysis of causal inference is grounded in the manipulation of counterfactuals. It is an excellent introduction to the topic, and a fine place to begin learning causal inference.
Its aim is to present a survey of some recent research in causal inference. Table of contents for counterfactuals and causal inference. However, when the counterfactuals posed are too far from the data at hand, conclusions drawn from wellspecified statistical analyses become based largely on speculation hidden in convenient modeling. The counterfactual conditional is the basis of experimental methods for establishing causality in the natural and social sciences, e. The main difference between causal inference and inference of association is that the former analyzes the response of the effect variable when the cause is changed. One such domain is the causal analysis of singular events in history. The following is supplementary data for this article. We research causal inference methods and their applications in computing, building on breakthroughs in machine learning, statistics, and social sciences. Counterfactuals, thought experiments, and singular causal. Causal inference is not an easy topic for newcomers and even for those who have advanced education and deep experience in analytics or statistics. Causal inference without counterfactuals springerlink. These models are based on ideas rst broached by statisticians in the early twentieth. In his own formulation of the counterfactual model, dawid assumed that a causal effect in an individual was composed of the average effect of treatment t versus c, an individual effect.
Counterfactual causality and empirical research in. Judea pearl is a professor of computer science and statistics at ucla. Models and principles for social research stephen morgan, christopher winship download bok. And this second edition by morgan and winship will bring clarity to anyone trying to learn about the field. Causal inference based on counterfactuals bmc medical. Models, reasoning, and inference, second edition, by. A counterfactual conditional abbreviated cf, is a conditional with a false ifclause. Causal inference uses counterfactual reasoning to determine if the data we see might have been different if a certain hypothesized causal. All causal conclusions from observational studies should be regarded as very tentative. Methods and principles for social research analytical methods for social research 2 by morgan, stephen l. He is a graduate of the technion, israel, and has joined the faculty of ucla in 1970, where he conducts research in artificial intelligence, causal inference and philosophy of science. You could put all your eggs on the propensityscore basket and hope for the best but i would advise it.
Causal inference and counterfactuals authorseditors. Explaining the output of a complex machine learning ml model often requires approximation using a simpler model. The essential features of the counterfactual model of causality for observational data analysis are presented with examples from sociology, political science, and economics. Counterfactual causality and empirical research in the. The stanford encyclopedia of philosophy provides an excellent discussion of the history and development of this approach. Counterfactuals, causal inference, and historical analysis. Causal e ects can be estimated consistently from randomized experiments. Causal inference in statistics, social, and biomedical sciences. It is di cult to estimate causal e ects from observational nonrandomized experiments. May 20 this workshop focuses on graphical causal models. Methods and principles for social science research by stephen l.
1404 775 340 1390 915 189 945 182 1074 143 617 1598 200 1375 1595 1181 1368 905 1077 1101 1244 1445 103 410 626 1099 1061 1445 1338 767 121 37 241 1002 66 1135 363